Hello dear
Welcome To Faicco's Italian Heros and Grill
At Faicco's Italian Heros and Grill, we celebrate the authentic flavors of New York right in Sarasota. Our story is rooted in passion for traditional Italian cuisine, offering a vibrant array of grilled heros and homemade specials. From our succulent hot sausage heroes to the rich, flavorful porchetta options, each dish is crafted with care and an emphasis on quality. The inviting outdoor seating allows guests to savor their meals in comfort, while our quick and friendly service ensures a delightful experience. Join us at 3590 Webber St for a true taste of Italy—just like you'd find in the heart of NYC!
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Italian Hero
Veal Parm Hero
Roast Beef Italiano Hero
Chicken Parm Fra Diavolo Hero
About
Faicco's Italian Heros and Grill
Welcome to Faicco's Italian Heros and Grill, a culinary gem nestled in Sarasota, Florida, where the vibrant flavors of authentic Italian cuisine come to life. Located at 3590 Webber St, this deli captures the essence of Italian sandwich artistry, reminiscent of the bustling delis of New York City. At Faicco's, the mission is clear: to serve fresh, hearty sandwiches crafted with quality ingredients and an unwavering commitment to flavor.
The menu at Faicco's boasts an impressive selection of heros, catering to a variety of tastes. Each creation is a labor of love, showcasing favorites like the American Hero featuring ham, turkey, roast beef, American cheese, lettuce, and tomato, or the indulgent Chicken Bacon Cheddar Hero, marrying fried chicken cutlet with bacon, cheddar cheese, and avocado. For those seeking a taste of something unique, the Homemade Porchetta Heroes offer a delightful twist, served with fresh mozzarella and broccoli rabe or smoky sundried tomatoes.
- American Hero: Ham, turkey, roast beef, American cheese, lettuce, tomato - $19.00
- Chicken Bacon Cheddar Hero: Fried chicken cutlet, bacon, cheddar cheese, avocado - $20.00
- Chicken Broccoli Rabe Hero: Fried chicken cutlet, mozzarella, spiced broccoli - $20.00
- Porchetta Hero 1: Mozzarella and broccoli rabe - $20.00
The energy here is palpable, fueled by the passionate team dedicated to delivering exceptional service and mouthwatering dishes. Patrons rave about the generous portions and the attention to detail that make each sandwich a memorable experience. As one enthusiastic customer noted, "It really does not get any better than this place! Unbelievable, friendly service, and amazingly awesome tasty food."
Moreover, the inviting outdoor seating area creates the perfect backdrop to enjoy your meal, whether accompanied by friends or even your furry companions, as dogs are welcome. The casual atmosphere, combined with the brisk delivery and takeout options, makes Faicco's a go-to spot for anyone looking to savor a taste of Italy without the extra fluff.
For those who have experienced the authentic taste of New York's Italian specialties, Faicco's proves to be a cherished piece of nostalgia. With each bite, one is transported back to the streets of NYC, where Italian delis thrive on tradition and quality. From homemade sausages to perfectly fried arancini, each dish is crafted with passion, ensuring that every visit leaves you craving more.
If you're in search of the ultimate Italian sandwich experience, look no further than Faicco's Italian Heros and Grill. Grab a friend, delve into their extensive menu, and allow your taste buds to revel in an unparalleled culinary adventure. With every bite, you'll understand why this deli has quickly become a beloved fixture in Sarasota. Don't wait—experience the magic today!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ It really does not get any better than this place! Unbelievable, friendly service, amazingly awesome tasty food that served in huge portions and a great outdoor seating area that is clean and comfortable. The folks here will put together anything you want with anything that they can put it together with. And seriously there is no better Italian sub shop anywhere in probably a 2 to 3 county area. This place is right out of New York with the quality of food the options available and especially the quantity of food. I cannot recommend a better place to go for a great Italian sandwich. ”
“ Let me start by saying this is the real deal folks!!! They brought NYC to Sarasota. PERIOD!!!! I have lived in NYC most of my life and with all the options to go to an yItalian specialty place for unbelievable Italian specialties and sandwiches It was ALWAYS Faicco's ! The food is amazing. It is as authentic as it comes. One bite and you will agree. When you know , you know ! They brought it all here. Arancini are delish and fried perfectly. The chicken cutlets fried fresh to order. They put them in the legendary chicken cutlets pesto and fresh mozzarella sandwich. BTW that sandwich is a must . The fresh roast pork with broccoli rabe is flavorful and juicy. They make homemade sausage. And if you're from the NYC and Italian you will be stocking up on the cheese and parsley sausage. If you're not from NYC and never had it , don't leave without bringing some home and putting it in the grill. I can't say enough about this place and the absolute joy to know it's right here in Sarasota for us all to enjoy !! Take a break from what you think is a good sandwich or meal and go try this place. You will soon understand why with all the competition in NYC they have been at the top of the list for years. NYC is still there but the graced with bringing it here. They are amazing and friendly and very fast service. You can say thank you later ”
“ We had fabulous sandwiches. Brought a bit of NY to Sarasota. highly recommend it. Very Good spot ”
“ I've been waiting for a good sandwich place in Sarasota ever since I left Miami. There are a few places I like quite a bit, but the sandwiches I had at this place is better than anything I ever had at a deli in Miami Beach. I am begging you to go get a pastrami from this place. ”
“ The food is the bomb Fresh and generous portions, meat available for purchase in bulk Fresh mozz for purchase as well as parmigiana and lasagna.... Picnic tables un- air conditioned But with food this good no one minds !! Service is quick and efficient ”
“ Delicious as usual. Second time having their eggplant parmigiana dish, take home and heat up. Will always come here! ”
“ If you're hunting for a place that delivers on big flavor and cozy charm, Faicco's Sandwich Shop is a must-visit. Tucked away like a true hole-in-the-wall gem, it radiates that old-school Italian vibe, complete with warm, welcoming family hospitality. I kicked off the meal with their rice balls, and let me tell you--perfection. Golden and crisp on the outside, creamy and cheesy on the inside, they hit every mark. The cheese pull? Absolutely next level. For the main event, I dove into the Italian sandwich, and wow--this one's a standout. The bread had just the right crunch while still being soft inside, perfectly hugging layers of the finest meats. Every bite was a mix of savory, fresh, and satisfying. But the real star for me was the Chicken Fra Diavolo sandwich. Picture tender, crispy chicken smothered in their house-made vodka sauce, topped with gooey, fresh mozzarella that stretches like a dream. It's rich, spicy, cheesy, and everything a sandwich should aspire to be. While I didn't save room for dessert, Faicco's more than made up for it with an experience that feels like stepping into an Italian family kitchen--unpretentious, authentic, and brimming with flavor. Would I come back? 100%. Whether you're a foodie or just hungry, Faicco's makes you feel at home with every bite. Don't sleep on this spot! ”
“ Food is without question, excellent. Lots of sandwich choices, with fresh breads, and a slew of Italian combinations. The service is as good as can be expected in an incredibly busy deli. Seating is outside and comfy but can be a bit hot in a Florida summer. This is a great grab and go spot, and the sandwiches are fantastic. Go! ”
